Find the demand, dispute it, rewrite it as a preference
TherapistAssist
therapistassist.app
Albert Ellis's REBT approach: unhealthy emotion comes from rigid demands ("must", "have to", "should"), not from events. This sheet finds the demand, disputes it, and rewrites it as a preference — the same wish, without the tyranny.
Activating event (A) — what happened, factually
Consequence (C) — what I felt and did
The belief (B) — find the demand
The 'must', 'should', 'have to', or 'can't stand it' underneath the reaction
Which of the three core demands is loudest? (about me / about others / about the world)
Dispute (D)
Is this demand logically true? (Where's the law that says it must be so?)
Is it empirically true? (What's the evidence in the real world?)
Is it helpful? (What does holding this demand cost me?)
Effective new belief (E) — the same wish rewritten as a preference: 'I'd prefer ___, and I can bear it if not.'
Emotional intensity BEFORE (0–100)
none
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
most
Emotional intensity AFTER working the new belief (0–100)
none
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
most
Option One
Get the Irrational Beliefs (REBT)
Print-ready PDF. Instant download — no account needed. We email you a copy too.
Option Two
Or send it to your client
Every worksheet, plus 80 interactive tools your client opens on their phone. No app. No login.
Albert Ellis's Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy in one page. REBT's central claim is that unhealthy emotion doesn't come from events (A — activating event) but from the rigid demands the client puts on the event (B — belief) — the 'must', 'should', 'have to', 'can't stand it'. The worksheet walks the classic ABCDE sequence: name the event, name the emotional and behavioral consequence (C), find the demand and identify which of the three core categories it belongs to (about me / about others / about the world), dispute the demand on three grounds (logically true? empirically true? helpful?), and rewrite as an effective new belief (E) — a preference: 'I'd prefer ___, and I can bear it if not.' Same wish, without the tyranny.
When to use it
Perfectionism where 'I must' or 'I should' generates chronic frustration or shame.
Anger driven by 'they must not' demands on other people.
Depression driven by 'life must be fair / must not be this hard' demands.
Anxiety driven by 'I can't stand it' catastrophizing about uncertainty.
How to use it
1
Separate A from C
The event isn't the feeling. Most clients merge them; the worksheet forces the split.
2
Find the demand under the reaction
'What must be true for me to be this upset?' Look for must, should, have to, can't stand it.
3
Locate which of the three demand categories
About me, about others, about the world. Different demand categories drive different clinical work.
4
Dispute on three grounds
Logic (where's the law?), empirical evidence (does the world actually work this way?), and helpfulness (what does the demand cost?).
5
Rewrite as a preference
'I'd prefer ___, and I can bear it if not.' The wish is preserved; the rigidity is dropped.
Frequently asked questions
How is REBT different from standard CBT?+
REBT is the ancestor of standard CBT. The key distinction is REBT's focus on rigid demands (musts, shoulds) as the driver of unhealthy emotion, and its emphasis on preference-based rewrites rather than probability-based rewrites. Both traditions live comfortably in the same treatment plan.
What are the three core irrational demands?+
Ellis identified three: 'I must perform well and be approved of' (about me), 'others must treat me fairly and kindly' (about others), and 'the world and my life must be easy and comfortable' (about the world). Most rigid beliefs collapse into one of these three.
Isn't this just positive thinking?+
No — the effective new belief is not 'everything will be fine'. It's 'I would prefer this outcome, and I can bear it if it doesn't happen'. The preference is realistic; the toleration is what removes the tyranny.
Is this worksheet free?+
Yes. Free printable PDF. Sign in to TherapistAssist to send as a secure client link.
Worksheet — Irrational Beliefs (REBT) — provided by TherapistAssist for clinical use. Not a substitute for assessment or treatment.
Guide for clinicians: Irrational Beliefs (REBT)
When to use it
Use it with clients whose distress is driven by rigid demands — 'I must succeed', 'people should treat me fairly', 'I can't stand this' — and who are ready for active disputing. It fits after you have taught the ABC model, because the sheet assumes the client can separate the event (A) from the belief (B) and the consequence (C). It is less suitable in acute grief or crisis, where disputing can feel invalidating; build the relationship first.
How to introduce it to a client
"Albert Ellis said it's often not the event that upsets us most, but the 'must' or 'should' we hold about it. This sheet helps you find that demand. First write what happened, just the facts, then how you felt and what you did. Then we'll look for the 'must' underneath and question it three ways: is it logical, is it true, and is it helping?"
Example
Illustrative example · fictional client "R.T."
A — event
Friend cancelled dinner for the second time
C — consequence
Furious, sent a sharp message · 80/100
B — demand
"She should prioritise me. I can't stand being let down."
Dispute
There's no law she must; she has a sick child; I've stood it before
E — new belief
"I'd prefer she kept plans, and I can bear it when she doesn't."
J.R.'s intensity after
40/100 — disappointed, not furious
What to look for when it comes back
Whether the client finds the actual demand. Beliefs like 'she doesn't care' are inferences; keep asking 'and if that's true, what must be so?'
Which core demand is loudest — about self, others or the world. Clients usually have one favourite that shows up across situations.
Disputes that are just reassurance ('she does care really'). REBT disputes the demand, not the facts.
The emotion after — healthy negative emotions such as disappointment or concern are the aim, not feeling fine.